Pantries are one of those things everyone has strong opinions about.
Most people walk into a design consultation convinced they want a walk-in pantry. It feels luxurious. It feels spacious. It feels like something you see in a magazine.
But here’s what I’ve learned over the years: it’s not about what sounds impressive. It’s about what actually works for your life.
A well-designed built-in pantry wall can be incredibly efficient. Full-height cabinetry with pull-out drawers keeps everything visible and accessible. It adds symmetry to the kitchen, keeps clutter contained, and often uses space more intelligently. For many households, it’s the more streamlined and practical solution.
A walk-in pantry, on the other hand, can be fantastic in the right home. Larger families, bulk shoppers, or homes with generous square footage can benefit from the additional storage. But without thoughtful layout and lighting, a walk-in can quickly become a dark storage cave where things disappear until they expire.
The real decision comes down to lifestyle, space, and how you use your kitchen daily. Do you want everything integrated and polished? Or do you prefer a separate zone where the mess can live out of sight?
There is no universal “better” option. There is only what fits your home and your habits.
And pantry design is one of those details that deserves more thought than most people give it. Because once it’s built, you’ll live with it every single day.
From my studio to your inbox: smart kitchen design, project updates, real-talk insights and my food and beverage favourites I can’t gatekeep.